Burning Menendez Case Questions Answered Amid Possible Resentencing

Solution for Eric and Lyle MenéndezThe murder case is filed more than expected for several reasons.

After in Eric, at the age of 53, an interview was renewed and with a high-profile Lyle case 25 years later, the Los Angeles District Attorney George Gascon announced in October 2024 that Hearing is defined against the background of new evidenceS Gascon said at a press conference that a decision would be made in November 2024, but since then he explained that he could make a request immediately after this week. Subsequently, the Los Angeles District Prosecutor’s Office recommended that Eric and Lyle’s sentence be reduced.

The brief explanation was bound by the fact that Gascon was for re -election when the residents of LA threw their ballots in November 2024. However, the longer collapse of Eric and Lyle’s request for resentment – which is years in creation – relies on several different elements of the legal system.

The case of Eric and Lyle’s murder has been playing up to the audience more than three decades after their parents, Joose and Kitty Menéndezwere found dead in 1989 and found a renewed public interest Due to the limited Netflix series Monsters and a documentary The Menendes brothersS And the brothers were arrested in 1990 on two first -degree murder charges. Two subsequent lawsuits led to the sentence of Eric and Lyle and a life sentence without the possibility of conditional release. Eric and Lyle, meanwhile, claimed that their mother and father were physically, emotionally and sexually violent and that their The actions were in self -defense.

The brothers’ legal team continued to file complaints From their sentence. Their last request was in 2023 when their lawyer after conviction Mark Geragos requested re -consideration while citing new evidence in the case as a Singer Roy RusilonThe previous ones against Jose and a newly discovered letter Eric wrote to his cousin Andy Kano Describing his father’s alleged sexual abuse months before the killings.

“We initially filed a request for the sentence to be annulled. This is the writing of Habeas Corpus. The other component of this is resentment. So these are two songs. You can pause the Habets as you consider angry. So this is walking and gum at the same time, “said Extremely Geragos US Weekly Earlier this month. “If Habeas will be provided, you will receive a new test. If they are outraged, the judge under the California law has the ability to recall the sentence and condemn it to a wide range of opportunities. “

Geragos whose past celebrity clients have included Winona Ryder, Cache, Michael Jackson and Chris Brown., seemed optimistic about the result The hearing. “I will not talk if [Erik and Lyle] have a plan [in the event they are released]S I just think to go every day, you just have to ground yourself, “he added. “It’s a long way out of life without [parole] For almost 17 years you are hoping. “

Continue to scroll for answers to some of the biggest questions why DA quickly query Eric and Lyle – and what will happen from there:

Why was the decision on their case moved up?

Gascon talks about his plan to submit an official recommendation earlier than expected. “As I said 10 days ago, I would make a decision within 10 days or so. I plan to make the decision by the end of this week, “he said during a press conference on October 22.” Yes, the end of this week. “

Gascón was ready for re -election with Nathan Hochman as his opponent. This ended with Hochman, takes his place in the District Prosecutor’s Office, which plays a role in Moving the decision on Menéndez case.

According to Variety300 people were outraged during the Gascon administration, including 28 people convicted of first -degree murder, and five who served life without conditional release.

If Gaskon is replaced, his decision will still make his way to a judge who will have to give up. In the end, Hochman confirmed in March 2025 that his office withdrew his request to reduce Lyle and Eric’s sentences as they did not show a complete view of their crimes.

A judge may subsequently allow the request to be withdrawn, but then the complaint will be an option For the legal team of MenéndezS The judge would depend on whether to grant Hochman’s potential withdrawal or to stand behind Gascón’s request.

What were the options for Eric and Lyle?

Gascón decided to resent instead of re -examining. In the event of resentment, the judge’s proposal would pass before the hearing of the Conditional Exemption Council. Eric and Lyle will either have to fulfill the remaining balance of the new sentence, or may be entitled to conditional release. (S)Variety they noted in their report that the governor Gavin Newsom has the power to approve or reject the recommendation of the Conditional Exemption Council.)

What comes after Gaskon’s request?

A judge will have to set a conference on the condition 30 days after Gaskon asked for a new sentence. Then it would depend on the judge Outrage Eric and Lyle on that day Or choose a later hearing date.

There is also the possibility that the judge may not agree with Gaskon’s request. Although unlikely, there is an option to refuse to reason that the judge finds that Eric and Lyle are “an unjustified risk of public safety danger”.

Gascon’s request will be considered by the judge, but it depends on the judge whether Eric and Lyle’s sentences will be reduced or not.

Can anyone object to the request?

Menendes brothers have Support from most members of their familyIncluding those related to the late kitten and jose. However, Kitty’s brother, Milton Andersonis honest that they oppose Eric and Lyle.

The Marcy law allows the people in California the right to be notified and heard during the proceedings, including their case, which would allow Milton to speak against resentment. Variety noted that Milton’s lawyer, Kathleen CaddyHe filed a request to be informed about the dates of the court and to be heard on the issue. Kadi also asked for a meeting with Gascon, but at first glance it has not yet happened.